Will The New 'Ghost In The Shell' Film Live Up To The Anime?

Being that this will be a "Europeanized" interpretation of GITS  and that most of the people seeing this film will not be familiar with the story's Japanime pedigree, I look for this film to stray from a lot of the deep philosophical and political themes the anime is known for. I, personally, have no problem whatsoever with Scarlett in the title role. She is at the very forefront of female action stars right now BAR NONE  with Lucy, The Avengers, Captain America, and Under The Skin most recently. However, being that this film is adapted from a story set in Hong Kong and the lead being recast from a Japanese woman to a white woman, I would have something to say about this if I were Japanese. But if they have no problem with this then why should I, right? Another factor that may affect this film's success is its long delay in being made and the director (Rupert Sanders) who's a virtual unknown. As anyone who's followed this film from Mamoru Oshii's original (based on the manga by Masamune Shirow) to the recent 'Arise' prequels knows, GITS, which itself is influenced by the film 'Blade Runner,' has been cannibalized by so many films from the Matrix on, that it may come across like a copycat of the films that copied it. I do believe that a director like Nolan, Greengrass, or even the Wachowski's could have at least guaranteed this film an intelligence close to that in the anime. I will see this film but I will go in the theater with realistic expectations of seeing nothing more than a dumbed down westernized live-action anime adaptation with loads of action and cool gadgets programmed to make as much money as possible. 

Raging Bull: anatomy of a boxing scene

An analysis of the film 'Raging Bull'

After brutally beating his little brother in front of the man’s wife and children, Jake faces his arch nemesis, Sugar Ray Robinson, for the 4th time, alone. He suffers a savage and bloody beating that results in him losing the title he worked so hard to win. The religious symbolism in this scene as it pertains to Christianity is powerful.

This scene represents the fall of Jake as a boxer, it’s all downhill from this point. The fight in this scene is Jake receiving all the punishment his conscience makes him feel like he deserves because of the beating he gave his brother and wife when he falsely accused them of having an affair. In this fight, Sugar Ray is the sum of all Jake’s sins requiring his blood for payment. The rope holding Jake up is a cross on which he is crucified and bloodied under Sugar’s barrage of punches. Also, at the beginning of this scene, the men in Jakes corner work on him as if they are preparing a man for death; the cornerman applying the vaseline looks like a priest giving Jake his last rites. 

The sound editor on the documentary said that he went for unusual sound effects for all of the fights, but for this one, particularly. When Jake is on the ropes waiting for his punishment, the crowd noises die out and a lion’s roar is cued to match Sugar launching himself at Jake. Also, the sound of winds howling replace the roar of the spectators at ringside. Visually, cinematographer Michael Chapman surrounded the ring with thick smoke to make it look like Hell and used the lights to transform Sugar Ray into a god-like silhouette representing all of the insurmountable appetites tormenting Jake’s soul. 

Analysis of a scene from 'Raging Bull'

This is an analysis of a scene from the film 'Raging Bull' after Jake La Motta is jailed for serving alcohol to a minor

In the film 'Raging Bull', Jake LaMotta is charged with serving alcohol to a 14 year old girl in his nightclub. He goes to prison where he confronts the demons inside of himself and comes out of prison broke but intact. He makes up with his brother Joey. 

This is the darkest and most powerful sequence in the entire film as we see Jake succumb to all of his excesses without the discipline and balance of boxing, his little brother, or his wife. As the film started with him in the boxing ring alone, in this scene he is also alone with himself to confront the question why? His unlit cell represents not only his isolation as a human but also the darkness of his inability to see that out of all the men he faced in the ring that he has always been his own worst enemy. Also, another note about his weight gain. Prior to his retirement, the training he underwent for his fights kept his weight from getting out of control. I interpret his weight gain as a metaphor for the accumulative effect of immoral behavior on his part.

With no way to offer penance with his blood in the boxing ring, all of his sins add up literally and figuratively. But, eventually, he comes out of prison, humiliated but repentant. When he sees his brother Joey whom he hadn’t seen since beating him for having an imaginary affair with his ex wife, Vikki, Jake begs Joeys forgiveness, kissing his little brother tenderly and crying. This is a powerful scene and marks the final stage in Jake’s character arc, going from a man living on pure appetite and impulse to a broken man in touch with his God and his humanity.

Analysis of a scene from 'Pulp Fiction'

This is an analysis of 'Pulp Fiction'. In this scene, Vincent Vega accidentally shoots Marvin in the face.

After the previous scene where Vincent and Jules got shot at point blank range without getting hit by a single bullet, Vincent and Jules are in the car returning the briefcase to Marcellus and Vincent is trying to explain away the miracle they just experienced. Jules is convinced that he’s out of the business for good once they return the briefcase. Marvin, one of the kids from the last scene, is in the backseat listening to them. Vincent turns and points the gun, not consciously, but carelessly, at Marvin to ask for his 2 cents and the gun goes off by itself, blowing Marvin’s face apart and covering the hitmen with blood. Now, they have to make a detour to Jimmy’s to clean the blood out of the car before they can drop the briefcase off to Marcellus.

This scene represents the blood sacrifice of an innocent, in this case, Marvin, for all of Jules' and Vincents’ past crimes. John 1:29: “Behold, the Lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world.” The blood in the scene symbolizes the blood of atonement, which will be washed away when they are “baptized” and forgiven and given new lives by the Wolf, played by Harvey Keitel.

Analysis of a scene: 'Pulp Fiction'

In this scene from 'Pulp Fiction' Butch saves Marcellus Wallace.

In this clip, all of the foreshadowing in previous scenes, from Jules asking the men that stole the briefcase whether they thought Marcellus was a bitch, and also saying that “Mr. Wallace doesn’t like to be fucked by nobody except Mrs. Wallace,” to Marcellus advising Butch not to let Pride interfere with him throwing the boxing match—these seemingly random statements that at the time seemed like banter have become a prophecy for Marcellus whose pride and body are violated by Zed, a  racist friend of the racist shop owner. As Marcellus is being raped in another room, Butch, who is next in line and still tied to a chair, miraculously loosens the ropes and leaves the dungeon. Marcellus was only moments ago attempting to kill Butch but as he is about to leave, Butch pulls a sword down off a shelf behind the store-counter and returns to the dungeon to free Marcellus.

Analysis of a scene from 'Pulp Fiction'

In this scene from 'Pulp Fiction', Vincent and Mia enter dance contest at Jack Rabbit Slims

In the film's documentary, Travolta said that this is his favorite scene in the whole movie as far as production design. I never thought about this scene a lot as far as being important to the story but having seen this film so many times and gotten over the shock of it I can see other elements in it I’d missed. This scene shows the effects of the weed they’d smoked in the previous scene. John is more relaxed and this is symbolized by him removing his shoes, which is something you do when you are very relaxed. Now, he’s not thinking he’s with his boss’s wife; now, she’s just another babe and when they dance, they’re actually flirting. I get the sense that Mia is not completely satisfied with Marcellus and that she likes the element of danger in flirting with other men. The dead celebrities around the stage are a symbolic of a warning to Vincent, that he’s flirting with danger and even death but he’s too high to realize it. 

'Pulp Fiction': Marcellus paying Butch to throw fight

In this scene from 'Pulp Fiction', Marcellus pays Butch to throw a boxing match.

Clip 1

Clip 2

In these clips, Marcellus pays Butch, an over-the-hill boxer played by Bruce Willis, to through an upcoming fight. Again, the dialogue in this scene foreshadows scenes to come later in the film. Marcellus is mostly out of view except for the back of his head and we see Butch’s face as he is being instructed by Marcellus to forget his pride. That word Pride is a word that Marcellus will be forced to deal with himself later in the film and though it seems ironic and random that he uses the word, it is not a coincidence. Asking a proud man like Butch to throw a fight is tantamount to rape, which is symbolized by what happens to Marcellus later. After getting Butch to go along with taking a dive, Marcellus adds further insult to this by giving Butch some money. Now, remember the question Jules asked the man in the previous scene, when he asked “Does Marcellus look like a bitch?” In street talk, a bitch is a  prostitute or someone who will sell their soul, which reinforces my belief that Marcellus’s soul is in that briefcase because he believes that money can buy anything. And, in movies, a briefcase is almost always connected with money.

So, by not only making Butch throw a fight but by also paying him to do it, Marcellus is treating Butch like a bitch, or a prostitute. 

Also, in this scene we see Jules and Vincent. Right away, you can see the animosity in Vincent towards Butch, for apparently no reason. But maybe this disrespect on Vincents’ part is because no one respects a man with no principles and the word’s gotten around that Butch has been paid to throw a fight.